Salvation and Isolation

Robert Unger’s book “The Religion of the Future” is one that’s stuck with me, for it’s ambition, for its ideas, and for how I both disagree with parts of it and absolutely agree with other parts. One part that reached me is his idea of Salvation as an ideal religious mode, that people all having a divine spark that we should cultivate and that is critical for humanity. Unger shuffled religions into three categories (Struggling with the world (Salvation), Transcending the World, and Humanizing the World) whereas I’d argue that the model is nice but religions may fit better as scales of each model. Still, he got me thinking, and I want to talk Salvation mode and spirituality/religion.

Namely, I think it is critical to our spiritual and psychological growth.

Salvation is a belief that we can all improve and be better. We can become Buddhas. We can become Taoist Immortals. We can be connected to God. We can awaken to our past lives. Whatever the idea, whatever commonalities or difference, the thrumming idea of Salvation is that we can all evolve and be better – there’s the Buddha mind, the divine spark, the primal elements, all within us.

We just have to get to work – which appeals to a project-driven person like me.

But Salvation also requires us to recognize the divinity in others – which is actually critical to our own salvation. To recognize the divine spark in others weakens the bonds of our limited identities of ourselves, to grip something higher and beyond ourselves. To cultivate it in others is to learn more about to cultivate ourselves and to find allies on the journey. It is also a reminder of our flaws, for when others struggle, we see our struggles and our own flaws.

The idea of Salvation is a way that takes down barriers and connects us. It’s uplifting and it’s humbling, and to refer back to Unger, I think it’s part of most of the religions he analyzes. From Confucian propriety to Taoist immortality to Buddhist enlightenment to identification with a Messiah, its everywhere when you see it. It’s even in psychotherapy and similar practices, albeit medicalized.

Salvation, in short, is inclusive. It has to be.

However, history – including modern history, seems to have a lot of people who talk salvation and yet practice isolation. For the purpose of this post, I’m going to focus on modern times right now (specifically 2026 CE) in America, and the right-wing Christian nationalist/exclusionist groups. As I listen to their leaders, look at their reactions, tolerate the testimonies of their figures like the unnaturally boring J.D. Vance, I see a supposed Salvation-based religion be about exclusion.

You’re not Christian. Not the right Christian. Probably the wrong color (even if some of these Exclusionary Christians want to say they’re not racist). They also hate Muslims a lot. They also probably hate me, and my guess is if you’re reading this, hate you too.

As I watch such people claiming Salvation, all I see is isolation. They don’t liberate others, they just want them to conform. They also don’t liberate themselves because they can’t – their idea of Salvation is exclusionary, based on being in an in group and others being on the out group. There’s no transformation, they just lock themselves in the castle of their politics, call it religion, and never grow.

Locked in together, people don’t grow. They just become the worst version of your group’s ideas. You lock out the world that you need to face for your own Salvation, then declare yourself saved because you’re not them.

There’s no recognition of a divine spark in anyone – including themselves. They locked it away behind the same walls they use to cut themselves off from others.

And such Isolation Religions (hey, Unger, use that) mean you don’t get better. You get worse. Everything is about THEM, of not being THEM, of being better than THEM. As long as you’re not THEM you’re right, your group is right, and you can excuse anything.

I think this model of Isolation Religion, of a kind of “anti-Salvation” is a useful model and explainer. It’s not just people who claim to be for Salvation but aren’t, they’re working hard to achieve the opposite. No wonder they bedevil us – it’s all they have.

–Xenofact

The Madness Of Moral Monoprinciples

There’s a book I’ve mentioned a few times here, The Unaccountability Machine. It’s a book of why things in the 21st century suck, how we changed, and how we knew better. The very short form is that businesses (and thus governments and culture) became obsessively focused on stock price/monetary value and went bonkers. We’ve normalized it, we’ve built our culture around it, but it is in the end insane.

Directing your entire life by a single measure, building a world around it, diverting all your resources to it, is a short-term thing. It will break, as we in 2026 are realizing by basically reading the news.

This is business, but let me suggest that it can happen in culture and religion. A kind of Moral Madness where One Thing Matters which supposedly serves as a foundation, but eventually goes completely mad. Call it a Monoprinciple.

The anti-abortion movement in America was my first inkling of this. I’d see politicians, pundits, preachers, and followers utterly obsessed with banning abortion. Everything swirled around that motivation without any kind of moral consistency – no care for actual living children, living women, etc. There was an air of madness about it, a spinning inconsistency, wild-eyed and disturbing – leading to bombings, murder threats and further insanity.

Of course this played to the power of various politicians and preachers, but sometimes I wonder if they ended up riding the tiger they raised from a kitten.

Confucians and filial piety were another thing that got me thinking about Monoprinciples. It’s not hard to read any form of Chinese Philosophy and see something on filial piety and respect for family roles. Anyone who’s dealt with a dysfunctional family knows that such things aren’t what they’re cracked up to be. Though my readings were mostly Taoist, I did read Confucian books and other works of philosophy and history and you can feel those moments writers had to reconcile these issues – usually very poorly.

A hint of madness over the years, trying to reconcile to the reality of some parents just being pieces of shit. A hope for a foundation that wasn’t going to ever be found.

In Influencer-infused Christianity of 2026, as AI write this, there’s a peculiarly shallow madness. Talk of Jesus, of God, of some Christian Principles that are so important. Then people are trying to sell you Bible shoes or preachers are involved in a sex scandal or some Church-scamming politician spews absolute insanity in terms of policy. There’s so many people talking about how they’re so Christian, but it doesn’t seem to mean anything. It’s an empty madness, a hollow phrase, a Monoprinciple that can’t even be examined it’s so hollow.

Everyone wants the One Magic Thing that makes it all work. Or at least lets them convince others it’ll work so they can sell merch and pass the collection plate.

But it won’t work. You can’t invoke one magic principle or one magic name that supposedly Encompasses All Principles. Life’s weird and complex, definitions play into each other, moral actions require careful measurement. Just like the “Line Go Up” madness of the business world was invoked to pay a bill now coming due, it’s the same with moral principles, trying for a single measure will crash, even if you’re no longer around to flee.

It reminds me of the Taoist idea that “having the Tao” provides morals, duty, stability. Having that unity, that sense of connection is where principles come from. But to cling to one thing is to have it all fall apart.

–Xenofact

The Spiritual Dilution of Showing Off

There’s a religious cycle I see regularly. Someone who’s a Christian, almost inevitably of an Evangelical variety, does some extremely public preaching, often to the inconvenience of others (say, on an airplane). People discussing them inevitably invoke the Bible, Matthew 6:5-6 (give or take):

5. And when thou prayest, thou shalt not be as the hypocrites are: for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen of men. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward.

6 But thou, when thou prayest, enter into thy closet, and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is in secret; and thy Father which seeth in secret shall reward thee openly.

(King James version, naturally)

I’ve seen this quote bought up many times over the decades and never thought about it too much. It’s advice against being a preening asshole and showoff, and hey, good enough for me. These people who supposedly know their Bible might want a refresher course and to also leave us alone.

However the latest round of this inevitable evangelism-leads-to-bible-quoting (a woman annoying people on an airplane) got me thinking. I’d gotten so used to this cycle, but in this case I got thinking about it more deeply. I suspect my own spiritual studies and contemplations of media had me in the right headspace to ask “why is this so important?”

Now I’m all for Jesus’ injunction against showing off spiritual practice. I mean I’m all for public rituals and shared spiritual spaces and the like, those have their place. But also that warning against being some big public religions showoff seemed so obvious I never analyzed it.

So I got to thinking about it. I also didn’t have to think much to realize that such a warning is actually pretty good for people of any religious persuasion. Yes, that includes atheists.

When you’re busy showing off your religious beliefs, really putting on the show for maximum exposure, it’s not about your religious beliefs. It’s about showing off, it’s about being noticed, it’s about whatever agenda you have. You’ve turned serious practice into marketing and influence-chasing.

When you’re in private in your spiritual practice, whatever it is, it’s focusing on the actual practice. The temptations to embellish, to show off, etc. are minimized. But when you’re alone, or maybe in a small group, you’re focused on what you’re supposedly actually trying to do.

When you’re running around in public engaging in aggressive religious behavior then it’s not focused on the supposed goals. It’s just showing off and has nothing to do with deeper beliefs. An emphasis on publicity inevitably leads to hypocrisy, and that’s not good for you or your (possibly unhappy) audience.

If you are actually sincere in your religious beliefs, you risk deadening them (and pissing people off). If you’re not sincere you’re just going to get worse and are probably avoiding the therapy you so desperately need.

I think this also extends, honestly, to public preaching in some cases. At my campus we used to have preachers show up in public space. But know what? They used public space, they kept to their own areas, I can respect that. They weren’t trapping someone on a plane or a bus.

Religious displays need to be approached with caution. You can end up turning your deep beliefs into a performance, and loose that spiritual connection to what you believe.

Also you’re probably being an asshole. But that goes without saying.

–Xenofact